This post contains affiliate or associate links with several businesses (which means if you shop through the links, I earn a small commission). As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
25 Popular Catholic Gifts under $25
It’s 2025 and most of us our shopping with a budget in mind. If you want. to give a meaningful gift, but don’t want to break the bank – you will find lots of happy options here!
Each gift comes from a shop listed in our Christmas catalog (download it here)!
Only some gifts are pictured, so be sure to look at the list carefully and click. to see more details about each item!
Popular Gifts for Catholic Women that cost less than $25
One
12th & Blossom has a variety of gifts under $25!
Shop for earrings, stationary, apparel and more! Here is a link to her items on sale!
Two
Gorgeous prints, stickers, mugs and more from Nichole Lanthier are priced under $25.
Nichole is an incredibly talented artist! She creates works that are seasonal and ones that are relevant the entire year. Shop art for your home or stickers for fun!
Three
A Book:
Catholic Mom Calm: Six Steps to Calm the Chaos of Everyday Life by Sterling Jaquith
want more gift ideas for women? Download the FREE 2025 Cozy Catholic Catalog here!
Popular Catholic Gifts for Infants, Toddlers and Young Children
Four
God Made the Moonlight by Erin Broestl
In this lovely read-aloud for ages 3 to 5, children embark upon on a journey steeped in the magical wonder of the moon and its Creator. A young girl travels from the city to the country, describing phases and aspects of the moonlight with a heartfelt understanding of beauty. “God put it there for all to see, but especially because He loves me.” Jean Schoonover- Egolf’s watercolor illustrations delight on this journey of simple faith and family life.
Five
Baby Crinkle Papers with Satin Tabs!
When my son was young, he loved to find and play with the tags on everything! He would have loved these! They are so sweet, you can get different patterns which include Saint Nick and the Nativity scene!
Six
Saintly Heart has a variety of fun bath toy play sets!
Their Quiet Mass Set is also under $25 and can be used as a bath toy as well. Bath Toy themes range from Jonah and the Whale to Saint Francis and Saint Florian!
Seven
Miraculous Medal Plastic Children’s Necklace
Perfect for a little girl who is to young for gold jewelry, Be a Heart has designed this cute necklace and is available for a great price! Use coupon code PRAYERWINECHOCOLATE to save a little more too!
Eight
Be a Heart also has chunky wooden puzzles that are great for the little ones too!
Nine
Sensory Boards for Catholic Kids!
Molding Saints creates sensory boards for children to play and learn more about Jesus, Our Blessed Mother, Advent, the Rosary and More!
Their mini-sensory boards are very cost friendly!
Here is one product description:
Mini-wooden Catholic indoor or outdoor Sensory Board that you and your child can play with during sensory time. It’s a great addition to your sensory play! This board is even easier to bring on nature walks and use it on its own. This sensory board is perfect for adding leaves, sticks, flowers to Jesus’s Crown of thorns during sensory play or collecting various wildflowers, grass, and sticks during your outdoor walks!
Download the FREE 2025 Cozy Catholic Catalog here!
Popular Catholic Gifts for Catholic Kids that are less than $25
Ten
Pixel Pillows from Nichole Lanthier!
Two of my children have told me they would like these as well as one of my nephews!
Eleven
A Catholic Magazine!!!
You can order past issues from Shining Light Dolls (my 8 year old son really loves this magazine). Past issues are about $5 a piece!
Another fun Catholic magazine that my 8 year old daughter enjoys is Rooted! You can order one issue for 9 dollars or sign up for a 3 month subscription for $25. Learn more here!
Twelve
Reusable Sticker Activities (Catholic Colorforms)
Shining Light Dolls has reusable sticker activity books that my 8 year old daughter still enjoys! Use coupon code PRAYERWINECHOCOLATE to save 10%! Also make sure you check out the gem art kits while you are there!
Thirteen
For Girls ages 9 to 13, the Be Yourself Journal is an awesome gift!
Be Yourself: a Journal for Catholic Girls is fun and incredibly reflective and helpful. Some pages can be done with friends and have a teen magazine feel; others will help the reader learn about God’s will in her life in a way that is exciting and enjoyable!
Grab one or more here!
Fourteen
For boys over the age of 8, Be Yourself: a Journal for Catholic Boys is a fun gift!
Be Yourself: a Journal for Catholic Boys has activities that engage the mind of young lads in a way other Catholic books do not. There is a “Mad Libs” like activity, a couple “Would You Rather” pages and solid advice for the boy in your life that is growing up. You can read more reviews here and here!
Download the FREE 2025 Cozy Catholic Catalog here!
Popular Catholic Gifts for Men that cost less than $25
Fifteen
A Saint inspired key chain for bottle opener from The Novena Rose Company may be the perfect gift you have been looking for!
The Novena Rose Company has a very popular key tray, inspired by Saint Anthony, and that is listed for $25.
These gifts are unique and fun! You can even order a personalized hanger for your favorite priest from this company for $24!
Sixteen
Know a Catholic Coffee lover?
The Joyful Mysteries Shop sells Catholic Coffee that inspires and awakes the soul!
Seventeen
A subscription to Hallow! You can sign up to start for free here: Hallow App
Download the FREE 2025 Cozy Catholic Catalog here!
Catholic Gifts for Teen Boys
Eighteen
Cross Pendant from Joyful Mysteries shop
This rhodium finish over pewter cross would make an excellent gift for men of all ages. It comes on a 24″ stainless steel chain and clear top gift box.
Nineteen
Books, comic books and apparel that is done well and often is appealing to those who like science fiction and reading.
Voyage Comics has a shop by age category. Lots of comics but so much more too!
Twenty
WWI Battle Beads from Rugged Rosaries
These are some really cool Rosaries. Definitely check them out! Decade options are under $25.
Twenty-one
Saint Socks and Apparel
Sock Religious has some fun socks for the whole family and shirts that perfectly blend humor with faith! This is a great store for teen boys and the rest of your family! (Socks are under $25; shirts a little over)
More ideas in the 2025 Christmas Catalog. Download the FREE 2025 Cozy Catholic Catalog here!
Catholic Gifts for Teen Girls that are under $25
Twenty-two
Bracelets!
These Rosary bracelets are priced at $25 – but look at them, they are gorgeous!!! Refuge Rosaries makes both. Rosary bracelets as well as other Catholic bracelets. The Catholic bracelets are priced under $25.
Inspiration Cuff Bracelet from Bee Still Design is another option for a different style!
Twenty-three
This Pray, Hope and Don’t Worry Mug is perfect for hot chocolate, tea or if she’s a coffee drinker! Throw in a gift card to give it that extra wow factor!
Twenty-four
A Catholic Sun catcher
Beatific Prism one decade Rosary Sun Catcher
Beatific Prism these beautiful one decade rosary sun catchers are so pretty. They will brighten a sunny space with beautiful colors dancing all around. They are so beautiful on a Christmas tree too.
Made of glass sun catcher beads with miraculous medal and Crucifix hung on silk ribbon.
Twenty-five . . .
How about a Cozy Catholic Candle? We have a blog post featuring three different artisans who create beautiful candles! Check that out here!
So many more in the Cozy Catholic Catalog!
More ideas in the 2025 Christmas Catalog. Download the FREE 2025 Cozy Catholic Catalog here! (MORE PHOTOS IN HERE TOO!)
